Synonyms / Other Terms Used
Trolley, Tramline, Tramway
Category
Transportation, Transport Facilities, Transport Modes, Travel, Public Facilities, Tourism
Message / Function
To indicate the location of trams / streetcars
Source | Description | |
---|---|---|
DB | Side view of electric tram with two sweepers | |
1) | ÖNORM A 3011 | Side view of electric tram showing sweeper |
DMU | Side view of electric tram on rails with three doors | |
Wiener Linien | Side view of front of electric tram on rails with door | |
ÖBB 2007 | Side view of front of electric tram on rails with door | |
UIC 413 | Side view of electric tram on rails showing wheels | |
Tern | Side view of electric tram showing wheels | |
CNIS | Side view of electric tram showing wheels | |
ISO 7001:1990 | Side view of electric tram showing wheels | |
2) | ISO 7001:1990 | Side view of electric tram showing wheels |
DMU | Side view of electric tram showing wheels and three doors | |
UIC 413 b | Side view of electric tram on rails showing wheels and several doors | |
Transport for London |
Side view of electric tram showing wheels plus several details | |
UN 1968 | Side view of electric tram on rails showing wheels plus several details | |
Galicia | Side view of electric tram on rails showing wheels plus several details | |
3) | WVB | Side view of electric tram on rails showing wheels plus several details |
NS 1980 | Side view of electric tram showing wheels plus several details | |
Bureau Mijksenaar | Side view of electric tram showing wheels plus several details | |
SVI | Side view of electric tram showing wheels plus several details | |
ISO 7001 | Side view of electric tram showing wheels and door | |
IIID In-Safety | Side view of electric tram showing wheels and three doors | |
Fuenfwerken | Side view of electric tram | |
Fuenfwerken | Side view of articulated electric tram | |
ASTRA | Side view of front of electric tram on rails showing two wheels | |
Swiss Post | Side view of front of electric tram showing two wheels and several details | |
Handbuch wien.gv.at | Side view of front of electric tram on rails | |
Erco | Front view of electric tram | |
O'72 | Detailed front view of electric tram | |
Bureau Mijksenaar | Front view of electric tram | |
EJP | Front view of electric tram on rails | |
Handbuch wien.gv.at | Front view of electric tram on rails |
Note: Some of the examples shown above were mirrored horizontally to contrast differences.
Discussion
Kristina Skone from the University of Vienna (1977) tested tram symbols with varying level of detail. The minimalist tram of ÖNORM 3011 in the table above performed best in this study.
Studying a set of 29 symbols from the Dutch Railways (NS 1980) in a Matching Test (Zwaga & Boersema, 1983) the pictogram for Tram was correctly selected by 71 % of the participants. While 84 % of the young respondents answered correcly, only 57.5 % of the senior respondents selected this variant. Confusions with Bus were quite frequent.
In a project concerning the comprehensibility of graphical symbols used on highways using a Comprehensibility Judgment Test (identical with the Comprehensibility Estimation procedure), twelve pictograms were examined in four countries regarding their suitability to convey the message Tram (Brugger, 2006). Pictograms displaying a long car body like the side view of a tram by Bureau Mijksenaar, but also a variant similar to the pictogram labeled as Wiener Linien above performed best.
Results from a Comprehension Test for three variants with differing degree of details (marked 1) to 3) above), showed that increasing the number of details does not improve symbol comprehension (Brugger, 1990). Pictogram No 27 from ÖNORM 3011 reached more than 90 % correct responses. It does not seem to be important to show the wheels of a tram, which usually are almost invisible in most modern models anyway, or to add doors and other details. Front views of electric trams should not be used either, as such pictogram variants (e.g. the Japanese version labeled EJP) cannot be clearly differentiated from front views of electric trains.
Recommendations
Based on the test results known we recommend the use of a simple version of a side view of an electric tram similar to pictogram No 27 from ÖNORM A 3011 part 2, or a simplified version of Wiener Linien (without door).
Tests of pictograms of referent Tram / Streetcar
Brugger, Ch. (1990): Abschlußbericht über den Verständnistest. Report to the Austrian Standards Institute (ON) dated 10/90, Vienna.
Brugger Ch. (2006): Comprehensibility Judgment Test. Report In-Safety, Contract No 506716.
Skone, K. (1977): Erkennbarkeit von Symbolvarianten. Dissertation, Psychology Department, University of Vienna.
Zwaga, H.J. & Boersema, T. (1983): Evaluation of a set of graphic symbols. Applied Ergonomics, 14, 1, 43-54.
See also
Updated 2023-09-10